In addition to their fabulous homemade peanut butter, one of my all-time favorites at Whole Foods is their warm butternut squash crab bisque. Oh my word – this soup is amazing! I still remember the first time a friend introduced it to me a few years ago, and I had my first taste of the brilliant sweet butternut squash and salty crab combination. It’s without a doubt my kind of comfort food. Absolutely delicious!
So of course, ran home and immediately had to figure out how to make it myself. A quick Google search came up with this recipe, and I’ve been using it ever since – with a few modifications. :) The original called for a cup of heavy cream, but I always use milk (or occasionally half-and-half) and still think it’s fantastic. I also added in a little extra crab, as I felt that its flavor was overpowered by the squash in the original recipe.
It’s a little more than a 30-minute meal, but well, well worth the effort. Plus, this makes an enormous batch, so it’s great for serving a crowd or yummy leftovers. A must-try during squash season!!
This looks fabulous. Definitely bookmarked for later!
This looks perfect for a crisp fall evening. I can’t wait to give it a try! Thanks for sharing.
I just made this an I’m in heaven. I can’t believe how creamy and succulent butternut squash can be. Thanks for the great recipe. I found you through the closet kitchen blog. keep up the good work
Just made this today, and it is amazing! Thank you for sharing it. I’m enjoying your website!!
Superb recipe, making it for Thanksgiving tomorrow. Thanks for all your good cooking!
Do you have any recommendations for the kind of crab to buy? Having never bought and used crab for a recipe I opted to try a canned version for the easiness of it. I used Chicken of the Sea Brand White Canned Crab meat and it had little tiny shell/hard pieces in it! icky. My soup was still absolutely wonderful but I could have done without the little hard bits! Thanks!
Eeks! I’ve never found bits of shell in my crab before. What an unpleasant surprise!! :S
I think I actually have used Chicken of the Sea before, as well as whatever other brands our various local grocery stores have on hand. (I’m not sure where you live, but in the Midwest, we don’t get too many options on crab.) But have never found shells thus far. Hmmm…wondering if I’ve just been lucky, or if you maybe had a bad batch…or what. Either way, sorry to hear that was your experience! Hoping for better luck next time!
I haven’t had any problems with shells with the Phillip’s brand. It’s a little costly but well worth it for the sake of your receipes. I will be trying this one tomorrow. I have never eaten butternut squash before. I can’t wait!!!!
I am spoiled because I live on the east coast, where crab is plentiful. I would recommend you search around at your supermarkets fish department, especially in the frozen section. I have often found that crab meat to be far superior to anything canned, and I am happy to say, tastes just like fresh crab I can get here at the docks.
Could I use squash that I already cooked? – its not pureed but its very soft/mushy because I baked it. I figured since it will eventually be pureed it should matter but it’s also already cooked so I’m not sure how that affects flavor and cooking times.
Thanks for the recipe – I am obsessed with that soup at WF and have been on the hunt for a recipe emulating it :)
Butter is not listed as one of the ingredients and yet the instructions refer to it: “Once butter is melted…”
Perhaps it’s a substitute for the olive oil?
Yea. How much butter do you need? Any? I plan to make this this weekend and would love to avoid unwelcome surprises like “How much butter do I need?” I assume 2 tablespoons as the adapted from recipe shows, but is that accurate? Thanks! This looks delicious and I can’t wait to try it!
OMG THANK YOU!! This is my favorite soup ever!
Good morning! I have featured this recipe on my blog today for my weekly seafood round-up and have linked this recipe to your original post so that my readers will be forwarded to your site. Thank you for allowing me to share! Here is the link: https://carriesexperimentalkitchen.blogspot.com/2012/10/seafood-frenzy-friday-week-39.html
The first item called for is roast garlic, but you do not tell how to roast it. I have never roasted garlic in the time it takes to cut up a butternut squash. Not sure what you were going for here but it should have been in the recipe. I guess I will just look for a complete one somewhere else.
Here are some easy instructions!
Delicious but I have to say I changed it slightly. My butternut squash (home grown) seemed a little small so I also used a medium sized acorn squash (also home grown). I only had white onions so I used them. I used more roasted garlic (I love garlic and always use more.) I also used a sprinkle of granulated garlic at the end (remember I said I love garlic.) I didn’t have access to fresh sage so I used dried and pulverized it to a finer powder with a mortar and pestle. I used white pepper because I didn’t want black specks in my soup if I had used fresh ground black pepper. I used all the chicken broth and an extra 1/2 cup half & half. I used a 1 lb. can of commercial Chicken of the Sea claw blue crab instead of 12 oz’s. Turned out FANTASTIC.
I just got some of this soup from my small town market in Old Saybrook, CT. They also add acorn squash and blue crab and it’s the best soup I have ever had! Thank you for your comments. I am going to try your modifications to the already great recipe!!
Made this for dinner tonight, and it’s YUMMY! I didn’t have sage, so I used thyme, and I added a little cayenne for a subtle kick. Also, I threw in a handful of shrimp I needed to use up. Wonderful!
I cannot ever follow a recipe but I love inspiration!! I subbed an apple for the celery because that is what I had on hand. I used coconut milk instead of cow milk and was generous with crushed red pepper. I love love love this recipe! Thank you!